Hey, It’s Me
EPISODE # 24
Hosts: Mike Sakasegawa and Rachel Zucker
Transcript by: Shea Aguinaldo
Please note: transcripts are transcribed directly from recordings of live conversations; as a result, quotes and statements may be approximate and there may be unintended memory errors.
Rachel Zucker: Hey, it’s me. I am calling you—or, leaving a message for you from a Lyft. I just landed at LaGuardia Airport and I am taking a Lyft to the Upper West Side, where I’m going to stay for two nights with my friends Alex and Deirdre. And I am leaving you this message in a way that I have never done before, because I’m speaking out loud, obviously, and the Lyft driver is, you know, able to hear us. So that’s just a funny thing to notice at the same time that I very self-consciously say to you: in your last message, were you inviting me to do an episode of Hey, It’s Me where we talk about the Elizabeth Holmes movie? If so, I excitedly accept.
I’ll just say quickly about the movie, You Can See Everything, I found it totally fascinating. I saw it with Lindsey the day before she left Maine. And I saw it primarily because Judah had seen it twice and was planning to see it again for a third time. And I really kind of wanted and needed to know what was so interesting about it to him. It felt like really important that I see it for that reason, primarily. But also, you know, knowing that it had become kind of the center of a cultural conversation.
As you know, I have very little knowledge of political or cultural current events, but this one snuck through and I wanted to be part of—to know what was going on. And I’m really glad I did. Obviously, I’m super interested in it from a documentary perspective and a narrative perspective and a feminist perspective and an artistic and craft and photographic, cinematic perspective.
Judah was here this past weekend, visiting me in Maine. I shouldn’t say “here,” because I’m in New York. But while he was with me we watched the new Sacha Baron Cohen movie, the Ali G movie. And I’m not saying—it’s not an artistic feat, and it’s not and shouldn’t be the center of the new cultural conversation, the way the Nathan Fielder movie is. But it’s certainly a really interesting movie to think about in connection to the Elizabeth Holmes movie. It’s a completely different genre. But both movies, I think, are very much asking this question about the authenticity of the self, or the stable self, or the knowability of ourselves and others. And truth, and whether we’re post-truth or not.
So, anyway, I’m super interested in this topic and would love to talk to you about it on or off the mics. Alright, I’ll leave you another message soon, when I can. I really have enjoyed getting your messages. I really appreciate it. Alright, love you.
[Music]
Mike Sakasegawa: So where do you want to start?
Rachel Zucker: Okay, well, first of all, I have a confession to make.
MS: Okay.
RZ: I missed the beginning of the movie.
MS: Oh, interesting.
RZ: I have a lot of feelings about that, but we're not going to spend the whole podcast talking about whether it was my fault or Lindsey's fault that we missed the beginning of the movie. But I would like to know, if you remember, how did it start?
MS: So we actually came into the theater a little late also, but right as it was starting because I was busy getting popcorn and I thought we had a little more time. I actually didn't realize that the movie had started at first. I thought we were seeing like a preview when it first started. [laughs] I think that it opens up on like a shot of the ocean. So at the beginning of the movie—maybe we should clarify, just in case it wasn't in the intro message that we're talking about Nathan Fielder's documentary about Elizabeth Holmes, which is entitled You Can See Everything. At the beginning of the movie, they are—Elizabeth Holmes and her husband, Billy, are renting a house in San Diego somewhere.
RZ: Oh, I didn't realize it was San Diego. Okay.
MS: Yeah, they mentioned it a few times. I'm not sure exactly where in San Diego, but it's right on the beach. I think that it starts with the view from their place, then just jumps right into them talking. I don't remember what they were talking about exactly.
RZ: When you say it's the shot of the ocean, it's not the shot that has Nathan Fielder? Well, yeah, the two people in the ocean, Elizabeth Holmes and you later find out it's Nathan Fielder. It's not that shot. It's just the ocean, empty ocean?
MS: I mean, I don't remember.
RZ: Okay.
MS: The thing is that it being the opening shot, if it did have people in the ocean, I wouldn't have had any context for knowing about it. And I've only seen the movie once.
RZ: Same, same here. Okay, so that's how we began, by talking about how you think the movie began. But maybe we should begin again with why are we talking about it? Or maybe what do you most want to talk about, about it?
MS: I mean, mostly I just want to talk to you about it. [laughs]
RZ: Me too.
MS: But I think one of the things that's really interesting about the movie, this is a three-hour-long movie. It is a little atypical for a documentary because there is no narration. And the filmmaker, Nathan Fielder, is in the movie as well. It's mostly just sort of… I don't know if I'm using this term correctly, but cinema verite, just conversations that they're having. Sometimes you see little snippets of conversations that Elizabeth Holmes and her husband are having. So number one, stylistically, the movie is a little unusual. I also hadn't been familiar with Nathan Fielder as a documentarian, though I gather this is not his actually first documentary work.
RZ: But I think it's his first feature.
MS: Okay.
RZ: Yeah.
MS: I had mostly been familiar with him as the guy in that meme from several years ago of "All my friends are laughing too. They're just outside of the frame."
RZ: I don't know that meme.
MS: I'll send it to you afterwards. I'll put a link in the show notes too. I also had some awareness that he had an absurdist comedy thing that may have been on YouTube. I think that they reference it in the movie. So it was interesting on that level. I was very aware of this movie because of all the people talking about it because of the trailer. The movie is three hours long and at the end of about two hours, it really feels like the movie is done. Then you realize there's a whole hour left. You're like, "What's going to happen next?" It goes in a direction that I was not expecting at all, even though people had been saying repeatedly, "You're not going to expect where this is going." But most of all, the thing that's most interesting about this movie is the way that people are talking about it that I've seen, where there seems to be… To use somebody else's description of it, I saw a guy named Red Scott, who is a friend of a friend. My friend Maggie Tokuda-Hall does a podcast with him. And he was talking about the movie on Bluesky because he was going to be talking about it for his own podcast. He said something to the effect of, "Everybody who is talking about this movie is in some way telling on themselves." I thought that was a really interesting thing. I saw him say that before I actually went to see the movie. But there seems to be a pretty broad range of how people have talked about the movie. You know, whether they are talking about it in terms of the filmmaking, or a lot of people are talking about it in terms of their impressions of Elizabeth Holmes, particularly, as a person, their impressions of her husband as a person, their impression of the dynamic between her and her husband. Apparently, a lot of people want to talk about whether or not she was lying or did anything wrong. Lying or did anything wrong during her time as the CEO of Theranos, or lying or did anything wrong during the movie itself, during the filmmaking process. I just found that really fascinating. My partner and I talked about the movie for like the whole evening after we saw it, then most of the next day as well. Both of us have a lot of experience, partly because of our neurodivergence, like really studying people's affects. She, in particular, has a lot of both personal and professional experience with narcissistic people, and people who lie, and what that looks like. But also, I know that when she and I are on the same page about something, it doesn't necessarily mean that everybody else that I know is going to be on the same page about it. [laughs] I really was interested to know—you're also a person who is very insightful about people and about dynamics. In your message that you sent me, you mentioned talking about it from a feminist standpoint. I wasn't exactly sure what you meant by that. So I just feel like I'm really, really interested to know what struck you about the movie, what struck you about the people in the movie? What were the things that you were thinking about, coming out of the movie?
RZ: Yeah, those are such great questions. First of all, I want to say that I listened to two podcasts about this movie. So they're both kind of in my head. One of them, Search Engine with PJ Vogt. The guest was Tyler Shultz, who was like the big whistleblower. To just say, I knew almost nothing about Elizabeth Holmes before going in to see the movie. That's one of the things that PJ Vogt and Tyler Shultz talk about in Search Engine, which is this sense that Nathan Fielder was expecting—to the extent that we know what Nathan Fielder really thinks about anything—that this was a kind of artistic, very interesting artistic film maybe about how can you interview a liar who you know is going to lie? And how do you look at media, documentary filmmaking, and knowability, and all of these things. But that the idea that a lot of people are going to the movie, as I did, actually knowing very little about Elizabeth Holmes, then being like, "Wait, I don't think she's getting a fair shot," or "Maybe she's telling the truth," or that maybe Nathan Fielder did not expect that response to the movie, like he expected—it's not even so much about what he expected. But the fact that people are rethinking whether she should have gone to jail, at least Tyler Shultz is saying, is completely beside—like, we know she's lying. There's ample evidence that she's lying. That's not what the movie is about. That it's a very interesting movie, especially if you come in feeling convinced that she is definitely lying. But this idea that people were advising other people to go in knowing very little, that was the thing that seemed to bother both of them the most, that the idea was more, "Can good storytelling obscure the truth?" Not, "Is Elizabeth Holmes telling the truth?" in a sense. So, one of the things that in both podcasts I listened to made me feel more like, yeah, this is what's going on is from what I understand, Nathan Fielder started as like a magician, basically. He was interested in magic. He was interested in comedy. His other shows, some of which I've seen, are really about like absurdist, as you say, but also like almost like a prank show that became a pseudo-documentary. It's really hard to tell where the line is. I think in my message, too, I mentioned Ross McElwee and Sherman's March. Did I mention that? I can't remember.
MS: I don't remember.
RZ: So Ross McElwee made this movie, Sherman's March, in the '80s. It was the first of many, many movies that did this thing where he got a grant to go back to the South where he was from to make a memoiristic documentary about Sherman's March. And instead, the movie has nothing to do with Sherman's March. It has to do with his previous romantic relationships. I really loved this movie when I saw it in the '90s. I think it inspired a lot, a lot, a lot of filmmakers to do this, like, memoiristic style, which is like not really documentary and not fiction either. So anyway, Ross McElwee came out recently with a movie called Remake about the death of his son, also about the possibility of remaking Sherman's March. But in any case, all of these movies, I think, start to ask these questions, which are questions that I am obsessed with in my own work, and in the literary work that I am so interested about what's ethical in storytelling? What's the line between fiction, memoir, nonfiction, creative nonfiction, documentary? I feel like that was what was most interesting to me about this movie. I'm also interested in this question of like, who is Elizabeth Holmes? Is she telling the truth or not? I'm fascinated by the question of how the use of her children in the film or the role or—all these words are weird and icky, as if she's a character, not an actual human being. But the effect of her children to the viewer makes me think about Sally Mann, makes me think about a lot of other artistic questions that we've asked. But—I feel like I just had the longest parenthetical within a sentence that I've had for a really long time—what's most interesting to me is Nathan Fielder and the director whose name I'm forgetting, Lance Oppenheim, and the format, the genre, the storytelling, the ethics of what Nathan Fielder is doing. What's secondarily interesting to me is Elizabeth Holmes.
MS: Hmm. Interesting. I feel like, so coming out of the movie, I felt, especially for the first two-thirds of the movie, I felt that the movie is really operating less as a documentary and more as a really intense character study of these two people. You know, Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans, I think his name is. The movie really goes out of its way to really scrutinize, not necessarily their stories, but to scrutinize their affects. Because so much of the movie, like I want to say the overwhelming majority of the runtime of the movie is shown in extreme close-up, where you can see every tiny movement that their faces are making. You can see every detail of the expressions on their faces, especially seeing it on the big screen. It's larger than life. Certainly, a lot of the people talking about it, one of the primary things people want to talk about when I've seen them talking about it online has been what an absolute monster Billy Evans is, how he is manipulative, narcissistic, possibly sociopathic, how he's controlling, completely amoral. And coming to the feminist reading of the film, how on one level, a lot of people want to take it as some kind of a story about a woman who has been traumatized, who is helpless by being manipulated by two charismatic but amoral men. Then I've seen other people responding to those takes by saying this is a woman who committed a lot of fraud, defrauded investors of hundreds of millions of dollars, defrauded patients to the point of giving them faulty information that caused them to have heart attacks, harassed people until they died. And because she cries in the movie, because she has these awful men in her lives, we want to treat her like this helpless little small bean who can't be held accountable for any of the choices that she makes on her own. So really, what is the feminist take on this? Is it to look at this dynamic and say this man is terrible, which he is, or is it to say she's also an adult human being who made choices of her own? I think that the presentation of the movie, the first two-thirds of the movie being so close in, just like physically zoomed in on people's faces like this, including Nathan Fielder's face, makes it really operate as a character study in that way. I think it really invites you to, as the viewer, to draw your own conclusions about what is happening, right? Especially because I don't feel like the film, especially because there's no narration, there's no interviews to camera, and Nathan Fielder never explicitly says, certainly in the first two-thirds of the movie, he never says, "This is how you should think about this." There is probably, in the way that it's presented, a more subtle, like, leading you that a documentary or a film in general can't help but do. But it does seem like the way that the first two-thirds of the movie is put together is inviting you to make your own judgments.
RZ: Okay, wait, I have to interrupt you. I have three pressing questions. One is quick. Do you remember the turn two-thirds in? This isn't a test, I'm just wondering, because it seems like there was a moment or a shift for you. Do you remember what was happening or how things changed?
MS: Yeah, at almost exactly two-thirds of the way through the movie, at the two-hour mark, she goes to jail.
RZ: Okay.
MS: You're like, "What's going to happen now?" And then there's this little montage of her going to jail. When she goes into jail, as soon as she walks in, people stop talking. You get this impressionistic little montage. Then the camera shows you this other person who hasn't really been in the movie so far. I'm like, "Is that Amanda Seyfried? Like, what is happening right now?" At that point, the movie really diverges from the entire, like, the whole style of the beginning of the first two-thirds of the movie.
RZ: Okay. Okay. Awesome. Great. You answered one question.
MS: Okay. [chuckles]
RZ: So the second question I don't want you to answer yet is you said, I can't remember your exact words, but like a documentary film almost can't help but let you know what the filmmaker thinks. As a character study, you're invited to make your own opinion, to have your own opinion about Elizabeth Holmes. But Nathan Fielder's opinion about Elizabeth Holmes is, you sort of said, hard for him not to give his opinion on some level in the film by the way he's making the film. I don't want you to answer yet, but I really want to know what you think Nathan Fielder's opinion about Elizabeth Holmes is. So can you, I'll write it down. Okay.
MS: Okay. [laughs]
RZ: So the third question is, let's assume that the movie is a character study of Elizabeth Holmes. I'm not sure I actually agree. I think the movie is a character study of Nathan Fielder. I think Elizabeth Holmes is incidental.
MS: Well, I just wanted to say, just to interrupt, I didn't say that the movie is. I said that the first two-thirds of the movie operates that way.
RZ: Okay. Gotcha. Gotcha. I'm sort of talking about the movie taken as a whole, but I wanted to go back to something that you said when you described going to see it with your partner. You mentioned neurodivergence. You also talked a lot about this very unusual filmmaking kind of technique in this, how close-up we were to facial expressions and to affect in particular, to Elizabeth Holmes' affect, and the largeness of it. I wanted to ask you to talk about that a little bit more. If you think that neurodivergence, what's the relationship between these filmmaking techniques and neurodivergence?
MS: So before I saw the movie, like before the movie even was released, people were really, really deeply analyzing the trailer that had come out. The trailer is a clip from the movie where the prominent part of the trailer is Elizabeth Holmes with this wide-eyed rictus grin on her face or smile on her face saying, "Why would I lie to you? I'm not lying to you. Why would I lie? What reason would I have to do that?" Then he's just looking at her like kind of a blank stare. He has that affect through most of the movie. I saw a lot of people interpreting that as what happens when, like, a weapons-grade narcissist meets an autistic person, which I have no idea whether or not Nathan Fielder is neurodivergent. I just thought that was a really interesting comment. What I will say is that for me, and for, I know a lot of neurodivergent people, one of the things about autism that is the most commonly, or one of the more commonly understood things about that is a difficulty or inability to read social cues, to understand implications, and a difficulty in communicating. That has to do with the fact that, in general, neurodivergent people, autistic people, tend to both communicate outwardly and receive communication in a more literal way, whereas neurotypical people in general are understood to tend to operate more through implication, and to mean things other than the literal meanings of the words that they're saying. And I know I've talked about this with you before—I think on the show, but I'm not entirely sure—but a big part of my experience of life has been absolute bewilderment about why people are mad at me. People thinking that I'm being difficult or that I'm trying to dominate them or that I'm flexing on them or people thinking that I'm being intentionally obtuse when actually what's happening is I'm confused. The course of my 47 years of life has involved me creating what I think of as a translation guide in my head of “when people say things like this, it actually means this.” Then conversely, “if I want someone to understand what I mean, I have to say it in this way, not in the way that I would naturally say it.” Of course, it doesn't work perfectly, but a big part of that has had to do with the fact that for me, understanding in general is not an intuitive process. It's a very analytical process. It's something that I have to think through explicitly every time. So when I am interacting with someone, especially when I'm interacting with someone who is neurotypical or who I believe to be neurotypical, I have to scrutinize their body language, their facial expressions, their tone of voice, what they're doing with their hands, and try to read between the lines on the words that they're using. So that has made me, of necessity, very used to trying to pick up consciously on very subtle details of people's affect. To put it in analytical terms, that's all data. You know, that is all stuff that goes into the translation matrix. You know, when a person uses these words and they say it with this body language and this tone of voice, it usually means this or this. But if they say the same words with this tone of voice and this cadence and this body language, then it means something else. It means this instead. So that's a necessary thing for me to be able to do to understand what people mean. The way that this movie is presented in such a way that you can see so many of these micro-expressions in such clear and fine detail, for a person like me, that gives me something to focus on. It's giving me data to understand what's happening.
RZ: Do you wish that you could always have that view of someone else's face, like that close-up data? Would you want this much data at all times, or would it be overwhelming?
MS: I mean, honestly, it was a little uncomfortable.
RZ: Yeah.
MS: I also think that it's uncomfortable for other people too. Although I think that part of it is not just a discomfort with holding somebody's gaze. Looking people in the eye is not typically uncomfortable for neurotypical people, where it is for me. But I think that what is uncomfortable for neurotypical people is holding a stare or a gaze in a way that doesn't feel normal. So if a person has a facial expression that seems unusual, if they don't blink very much, if they seem like they are in emotional distress for some reason, those are things that often set off alarm bells for people and makes them very uncomfortable. I've seen a lot of people talking about that with respect to both Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans.
RZ: Okay. Thank you for talking about that. I also don't know if Nathan Fielder considers himself to be neurodivergent, if other people in general consider him to be neurodivergent. I certainly noticed some things about him, and I've noticed these before in other things that I've seen. Often it's a quality that he has that can make me quite uncomfortable. I never know how much of it is cultural. It comes across very differently, but Larry David has this, Sacha Baron Cohen has a version of this. Jerry Seinfeld has a version of this. All of these are Jews so far that I'm talking about, Jewish men. But again, whether it's genuine or not, I don't know, because I think Nathan Fielder's work is all about making us question what is genuine. On one of these podcasts, someone brought up Penn & Teller, the way in which they first explain how there is no magic, the magic is not real, so to speak, then they do magic or they do things that no one can understand. That authenticity is the misdirection. I thought that was a very helpful phrase to think about Nathan Fielder's work, how you can't really know what's genuine because that's almost always what the central question is for me in his work. And I don't always love… Sometimes there's a real meanness that comes up in work like that. On the other hand, I think that his—sometimes you could read it as confusion, which is a little bit similar to what you're saying. He doesn't seem to get certain things that people would ordinarily assume. He doesn't assume. He asks a question or he'll ask it again and again. He'll sit with this discomfort of not knowing. Or you'll read what you think is maybe he doesn't know what's going on. It's not clear to me whether this is part of his genius, whether this is a performance, whether this is kind of just how he understands the world. I do think it makes him a really good interviewer. So one of the things I wanted to also bring into this conversation between you and me, two podcasters who have interview shows, what did you think about him as an interviewer or him as a—it's both unusual, and also, I think, a style.
MS: Yeah. Well, this gets to the question of—or it pertains to a question, which is, “is he autistic?” or something like that. Because this was something that my partner and I talked about after the movie also, just like what you're saying, it's really hard to know... He does this thing when Elizabeth Holmes is talking to him or when Billy is talking to him or even when Amanda Seyfried is talking to him where he doesn't usually respond immediately when it's “his turn to talk," right? He takes a pause. Then a lot of times he'll get stuck on something where he will ask the same question. He's like, "But come on, really?" You know, that kind of thing. At the same time, he has a very blank expression on his face. So one way that you could read that is, "Well, he's autistic," right? He's taking a pause because he needs to process and do that translation process that I was talking about. He's asking clarifying questions because he doesn't understand. He's got a flat affect because autistic people have a flat affect. On the other hand, he could be doing that consciously. That could be something that he's like, "I'm going to keep my face very blank so that the audience, and the person I'm talking to, don't know what I'm thinking. I'm going to take a pause here because that will make the situation a little off balance. I'm going to ask these questions that most people wouldn't ask because it will elicit a different kind of response." I think that whether it is done naturally or calculatedly, it does produce an interview that is atypical. It produces results in the interview that I think… Especially if one assumes that the people that he's talking to are either consciously or unconsciously trying to hide things or manipulate the situation, the way that he approaches them kind of disarms that. It disrupts that energy. In terms of interviewing, I think that I notice similar things in the way I approach an interview, right? That when—anybody who has listened to Keep the Channel Open will notice that I typically ask different questions than what a normal interviewer will ask. I oftentimes will ask questions that require an explanation of something that might otherwise just be implicit. I often pause. That's a little less evident in the final cut because I do edit those for pacing. Also, that I have a tendency of allowing silences to stretch on. These are things that when I do them, part of it is not exactly calculated, but it is, for example, allowing someone else to fill the silence in is something that I'm aware of as an interviewing technique. But also the kinds of questions that I ask people are really driven by what my interests are, and what I do and don't understand. I'm not usually interested in having a conversation with someone where they just say the same thing that they've said to every single person on their book tour. I want to get at something that's a little bit more intimate, and not necessarily something that they've had lots of time to craft their answer, you know? So I do notice certain things there that are different. What's interesting, though, is that you do a lot of the same things and I've never really considered you to be autistic, you know?
RZ: Yes. Can you tell me when we're at exactly the two-thirds mark of this interview so that I can veer us off into a wildly different direction?
MS: [laughs] I would have to know where it's going to end first.
RZ: Oh, really? You have to know? But then you won't be surprised.
MS: I'm just saying, how can I know?
RZ: Oh, you just meant temporally. You meant you don't know.
MS: Yeah.
RZ: Oh, that's a great point. You didn't mean like which, where I was going to take us.
MS: No, I just mean, how can I know it's two-thirds if I don't know what one-third or 100% is?
RZ: Oh, god. This is terrible.
MS: But I wanted to also, this thing that you were talking about in terms of authenticity, bringing up the Sherman's March thing, bringing up Sacha Baron Cohen, you had mentioned in the message that you left me that you had gone to see the new Ali G movie, which I have not seen. I have seen several episodes of the original Da Ali G Show. I also saw one of the Ali G movies, but the one that was very clearly fictional, and had nothing to do with his… You know? But the Ali G show is an interesting thing. Sacha Baron Cohen, whether it's Borat or Ali G, his whole thing of this is documentary. He's playing a character towards people who don't know that he's playing a character. That's a big part of it. That definitely bears on this movie, because when you get into that final third of the movie, a lot of what's going on is—so, as always when we're talking about stuff on this show, we're going to talk about the whole thing. So spoilers or whatever. The final third of the movie is he brings in Amanda Seyfried, who played Elizabeth Holmes in, I think, a Hulu or Netflix or something, a Hulu series dramatizing the Elizabeth Holmes Theranos story. He brings her in, he shows her the whole what you've just been watching, brings her into the project. And she both is involved in the documentary process in terms of she has meetings with Billy. She is talking with Nathan Fielder just as the two of them. Then they do reenactments of things that they weren't able to—and some of the reenactments are reenactments of things that Nathan Fielder says really happened, but they didn't have cameras rolling. Some of the things, like whether it's his visit to her in prison or things that happened before the principal photography started, like in the meetings beforehand. Some of the things are just guesses. Some of the things are just like, "I'm speculating about this." One of the things that I think that does, that final third hour of the movie does, is it really foregrounds the artifice of the movie. It really foregrounds the fact that Nathan Fielder is being a "character" in the narrative, especially because, at least for me, it got a little hard to tell at times. You have this actress in the movie now. There is no difference at all in the visual qualities and the visual language of the scenes where it is Nathan Fielder talking to Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans in their home, and him talking to Amanda Seyfried in her home, and Amanda Seyfried reenacting scenes with Nathan Fielder. There's visually no difference between these things. Stylistically, like cinematographically, no difference between these.
RZ: Right. He could have done it in black and white. He could have used a different lens. He could have used different lighting. He doesn't do any of that. It's totally the same unbroken narrative frame in terms of visual cues to the audience. Yeah. Keep going.
MS: Yeah. There are times when in that final third of the movie where he intercuts reenactment with sort of live conversation that he's having. So he's having a pre-discussion with Amanda Seyfried about what happened. Then he cuts in with her reenactment of it. But I think that that is in some way—and I know not everybody agrees with me. My partner didn't really agree with me about this—that I think that this is intentionally calling into question, well, is this part where Amanda Seyfried is as herself talking to Nathan Fielder as himself, is that actually what's happening or is that scripted? It's kind of impossible to know that. The argument here would be like, well, Amanda Seyfried is not a good enough actor to make that so convincing. And maybe that's true, I don't know. But I also don't know. Maybe she is, like, who knows.
RZ: Yeah. One of Nathan Fielder's previous shows, which I've watched a few episodes of, but frankly, his earlier work, and this to some extent, have made me feel so uncomfortable. You know, my youngest son has watched all of Nathan Fielder's stuff, really feels like Nathan Fielder is like the uber artist of his generation, which is interesting to me. And that's why I initially went to see the film.
MS: I mean, in terms of visual artistry, even the very beginning of the movie, the first thing that you see, now that I remember this, he shows you this later in the movie also, is Billy lying in Elizabeth's lap. It's a close-up on his face. Then there's like some, it's like a very sort of blue-toned scene with this little sliver of light playing across his face. As a photographer, me, I'm looking at this composition, and at the way that the light is in this thing. I'm saying, "How could that possibly just be how he was laying?" It looks like a lighting director would do that on purpose. It looked like something out of the movie Moonlight. Do you ever see Moonlight? Is that really just what the light happened to be like in this room? That seems crazy to me.
RZ: Yeah. In one of his earlier shows, The Rehearsal—do you know the basic premise of this television show?
MS: Yeah, not really.
RZ: So people are going to, let's say, propose or have a difficult conversation, let's say, with a parent. The premise, but the show does a lot of twists and turns, is that Nathan Fielder comes and meets the person, and helps them rehearse for this live interaction with a family member, a real, genuine interaction. In one of the episodes, I think that the place where the subject—I mean, even that I called this person the subject—is going to have the conversation with someone else is in a bar. At this point, The Rehearsal's on HBO. So Nathan Fielder recreates down to the very detail on the set, the bar, so that he can bring this person into this set to rehearse for a real live conversation in the real world. Also, he rehearses how he's going to tell the person with whom he's rehearsing. So it's levels and levels of, as you said, like artifice. He wants to show us that he is making this movie all the time, that this is a made thing, but it's also ostensibly about real people who are acting as if there's no cameras there. You can see everything, including how the movie is made. Sometimes you can see the boom in the shot. I think that's very intentional that he leaves those shots in. I think… I haven't yet asked you what you think Nathan Fielder really thinks about Elizabeth Holmes. We haven't talked about the potential feminist readings of this, but I'm going to veer us.
MS: Okay. [laughs]
RZ: So I think one thing that this movie really brings up is this issue, which for me has been an obsession, maybe a personality trait, maybe an artistic obsession, maybe a mental illness, or maybe the way in which I might be neurodivergent. And it has to do with a real preoccupation and lack of confidence in knowing what is real, and the way in which I feel I'm slipping in and out of the character, narrator, authentic self roles in my "real life." So I just wanted to share when in my narrative timeline I saw this movie, and give you a sense of how, in addition to all the stuff we're talking about now, this movie really was kind of both frightening and helpful to me.
So the weekend before I saw this movie in the theaters with Lindsey—and just even who Lindsey is is a whole You Can See Everything type of moment for me. She was an undergraduate student that I had at Fordham in, I guess, 2005. Then when she graduated, she became a babysitter for me, for Moses and Abram. She was at Judah's birth. She was Moses and Abram's birth buddy. So she was in charge of making sure they felt comfortable. Then she babysat for Judah, and then was a big part of my life as a friend. She lives in Montana. We've always kept in touch and been very close.
Then when Abram was dying, she came and she was very present and hands-on, amongst a very inner core of people who were really hands-on with Abram in a physical way at his dying. And then as I got closer to the one-year anniversary of Abram's death, I was having some pretty extreme problems with loneliness and with anxiety. Lindsey drove from Montana with her dog and spent three weeks living with me.
So Lindsey just turned 40. I'm 54. You know, the roles that Lindsey and I have played in each other's lives are so varied. The difference between teacher, undergrad, and 40- and 54-year-old living together and supporting each other at this particular time in life is pretty wild. Then she helped me. The plan was that she would be with me for two weeks before the celebration of life, then for a few days afterwards, so that when everybody else left, I wouldn't be left all alone. Then she would leave.
So, a few words about the celebration of life. So I invited many of my closest friends to come, I invited you—you were not able to come, that is okay—to come to Maine. My friends and also Abram's friends. It was like a wedding, really. There was a dinner Friday night at the restaurant that Abram worked at, one of the two restaurants he worked at. Then Saturday had different events. We had a lunch all together. We sat in a circle outside and talked about Abram, and talked about grief. Some of us went in the ocean together. We had a sunset meditation led by Moses, my oldest son. I made 18 pounds of brisket in the week leading up to. I had made dinner for everybody that we had at this clubhouse that's not that far from where I live. It was one of the most incredible experiences of my life, and very surreal, and very, at times, absurd and strange and joyful and wonderful.
Because my actual wedding, I think, was really more Josh's wedding. It was mostly his family and his friends. I felt very uncomfortable at all of the attention, which was directed towards me and Josh. But at that point in my life, I felt uncomfortable in my physical body.
But this was like maybe the wedding I always wanted because I only invited the people I wanted to be there. Most of my friends—a few of my friends know each other, but most of them don't. It was wild. It was wild to see my friends hanging out with each other, laughing, meeting each other. You've all heard about each other for so long. Then also interacting with Abram's friends. It was just unbelievable, but also unbelievably trippy. As if multiple dimensions had suddenly come together. Like, "Wait a second. My friend Monica lives in Rotterdam, but here she is hanging out with Joan, who is from a totally different part of my life. They've never met. They're both from New York." People figuring out what people had in common, seeing how people interacted with each other. And also feeling that everyone had come for me and for Abram. And really enjoying that attention, and feeling seen, and feeling supported. And then on Sunday, everybody left.
I've had a very difficult time in this past year living in Maine with reality because I went from being a New Yorker who had a million different jobs, and taking care of three kids, all this stuff, to being suddenly—well, then I had 15 months of medical drama in which I was recast, so to speak, as this primary caregiver to somebody with advanced cancer. All of a sudden, I had like a whole different part of my life. Then all of a sudden I'm like living in Maine in this very isolated, grief-stricken place where—and we've talked about this on previous episodes. I think we may have talked about this last time, but one of the reasons why grief, and particularly an out-of-order loss, a life-changing loss, a traumatic loss like the death of a child, is mentally and cognitively disabling is because I had to teach myself through experience, every minute of every day—and for me, it really took a year—that Abram was dead. We have not evolved to have an acceptance of death as an abstract concept. I had to learn that every single day. It was impossible. On some level, it is still impossible to me that he is gone.
So who was to say what was real? What was in the present? What was in the past? I was having these dissociative episodes. I was having these flashbacks. I was not anchored in space and time for over a year.
Then I started to somehow come back into the mainstream, the thing that all the rest of the people who were not in my grief bubble with me considered to be real. But when I came back in, I had this incredibly impossible experience of seeing all these people from all over the place together in a way that seemed like a dream. It seemed like a movie. It seemed like a movie. And then everybody left. Then it was just me and Lindsey. Then we went to see this movie. [laughs] And then Lindsey left. And then I went to New York City. And all of a sudden, I was like back in New York City on the Upper West Side.
MS: All of this is like just in the past couple of weeks.
RZ: Yeah, less than two weeks. So I'm walking around New York City, and I feel that old confidence and a sense of belonging and a sense of familiarity that I don't feel in Maine. But also a sense of, like, everyone else—like, here's somebody pushing a baby carriage. Here's somebody talking on the phone about finance this and that. Oh, and I arrived on the day of the election, which was a whole other, like, "Is this real? Please let this be real. Is this happening?" You know, especially for somebody like me who has been so removed from the news, and not keeping up, so to speak. Again, just like in bubble inside bubble inside bubble inside bubble of just like obliterating grief to come back into what I guess is the real world, but to still feel as if everybody else's life is more real than my life is. Often I still feel like I'm watching a movie when I'm interacting with other people.
I also just took a five-week acting class, which I've never done. I'm writing this novel. I'm like deep in my novel, which is clearly autofiction. I'm telling the same stories over and over and over again in the novel, but in different contexts. Part of what the novel is about is what is real? What really happened? What is a transcript of a podcast? What is a transcript of an audio message? What is a remembered conversation? What is an imagined conversation? Then meanwhile, I'm going about in my "real life," seeing the characters in my novel, such as myself, my father, my children, and not knowing, like… Do I believe Elizabeth Holmes is lying? Do I believe she's aware that she's lying? I'm walking around LaGuardia Airport thinking, "I don't know if I believe myself. I don't know if I believe my own thoughts. I don't know if right now, am I just living?" Yes, I'm living. I'm a human animal who's doing these things. But I'm also constantly playing a role, whether it's the role of the person getting on the airplane. And if anything interesting happens to me, there's a part of my brain that is constantly recording the experience, the live experience, to put in my novel, to talk about in therapy. When I'm in therapy, half of my brain is recording the therapy to go in the novel. When I'm writing the novel, half of me is, "I'm going to tell my therapist what I'm writing about," or "I'm going to tell you what I'm writing about." There's layers and layers and layers. I am, on some level, there are invisible cameras. This is after that movie, what's the movie where the whole, he's a real baby in that totally fake set, but he doesn't know it? What’s… Come on.
MS: The Truman Show?
RZ: Yes, The Truman Show. So I know a real psychiatrist who said that after The Truman Show, when people have psychotic breaks, there are waves of different themes to their psychotic episodes. And believing that you were in The Truman Show became a very common belief for people with psychosis. And I can see why. Am I hearing voices? Yeah, I'm always fucking hearing voices. I'm hearing my thoughts. I'm hearing the things that other real people are saying. That becomes dialogue. Sometimes it really becomes dialogue. Sometimes it becomes forgotten dialogue. I'm constantly using my phone to record, visually and audio, all of this stuff. I really was, I guess, having what I now consider an Elizabeth Holmes moment where I don't know what's real. I don't even know what's knowable. Like, she definitely lied. She 100% lied. Does she believe herself? I don't know. I suspect that I have felt what she seems to feel, which is… I believe her when she says—and it doesn't even matter whether I believe her or not, but I do—I believe her when she says, "I was trying to communicate as clearly as I could." Sometimes. I believe that she's convinced herself of that. So, I don't know. I guess that's what I also really wanted to talk about, about just like… You know, I've talked on Commonplace about the authentic self. Is there an authentic self? Is there a continuous self? But my latest experience with this question of reality seems bizarrely captured by this movie, even though I have nothing in common with Elizabeth Holmes. But I do have a lot, I think, in common with Nathan Fielder, even though in other ways I have nothing in common with Nathan Fielder. But I do feel like my movie— [laughs]
MS: That was a nice little slip there. [laughs]
RZ: Right. I feel like my life is currently being produced and directed by Nathan Fielder.
MS: I mean, I think that this is going to probably reveal my incomplete, layman's understanding of a lot of different psychological and psychotherapeutic terms, but I mean, isn't something about the idea of things like parts work or shadow self work, the idea that there isn't, like, one unitary you? There's not like one master control thing that's happening in your brain, but rather there are different parts of your psyche that are interacting all the time. And those things are not always working in concert with each other. They're also not stable from moment to moment. I kept thinking about that conversation that you had with Doug Kearney a long time ago on Commonplace, where he made the assertion that performance is authentic.
I mean, I've certainly had moments, many moments in my life where it felt like I was looking at it from the outside. They tend to be the moments that are emotionally laden. I remember very clearly having this moment, maybe a month or two, month and a half before I graduated from college, sitting on a couch in the quad of my dorm, thinking, "Am I really going to be leaving this place in six weeks?" I remember feeling that way when each of my kids was born. I remember feeling that way when I got married the first time. I remember feeling that way when I went to Japan to meet my partner. I mean, there are lots of times when I have felt that way, when it felt like, "I don't feel like this is really happening right now." I think that's a pretty common experience, or I don't know.
But I also think, another thing that you were just talking about is whether Elizabeth Holmes was being sincere in any of the things that she was saying, whether she has convinced herself of anything. I think that it is something that is certainly not well understood—based on the kinds of conversations I see people having about this movie, it's not well understood by everyone how powerful self-deception can be, and how necessary it is for the survival of a person's ego.
One of the things that my partner and I were talking about after this movie is I recently read this book called Why Fish Don't Exist, by Lulu Miller. It is about this guy who was the founding president of Stanford University. He was a naturalist. He studied fish. It's about a lot of different things but primarily… It's interesting; the book actually starts off in a way that you think that it's going to be about this man, but it is actually about Lulu Miller. It is actually about her difficulty and struggle with finding meaning in life in what appears to be a clockwork, uncaring universe. That’s, now that I think of it, very relevant to the kinds of things you were talking about with this movie, with Sherman's March.
But one of the things that she talks about in this… I think the man's name is David Starr Jordan. I could be wrong about that, but she reads his journals and how much of a regard he has for himself, despite the fact that sometimes he does stuff that is, at the very least, weird, but definitely some of the stuff that he says is very fucked up. He was a big proponent of eugenics. But one of the things that she brings up in that is how, I think in the 1970s, this phenomenon was studied and it became a big part of parenting advice and teaching, like pedagogical advice, that researchers noticed that the people who are the happiest and most well-adjusted in seeming in their lives tend to be ones who have what they call, I don't remember the exact term, but it's like something like a benign self-deception, where they just see themselves as being just a little bit better than they actually are. Meanwhile, the people who are the most honestly self-aware tend to be depressed and anxious and resentful.
RZ: I don't know who you're talking about now.
MS: I could be talking about both of us. [laughs] And it was interesting, too, in the book that she goes on to talk about this fad that took hold in the '80s because of this, where parents and teachers were really encouraged to—I mean, the whole, this got mocked a lot in the '90s, the whole Stuart Smalley “Daily Affirmations” thing. But where you're encouraged to do little things to inflate your ego a little bit. The problem then being that researchers later found that people, yes, are happier in general when they have these little illusions about themselves, but also when those illusions are popped, that they have a much bigger problem with it, and often can lead to violence or self-harm.
RZ: The problem was with praising, and then you were supposed to praise effort, not ability. Yeah.
MS: Yeah. So it's a parenting and teaching fad that's gone out of vogue since then. But just this idea that lying to yourself on some level is kind of necessary for your mental health, or at the very least that the inability to lie to yourself is intolerable.
RZ: Right. So there are two things I think that are so important here. One, you're saying so, so well, like the lying to yourself is kind of necessary in a certain way for sanity. I would say the other is seeing your life as a story. There have been times for me when stepping back enough to see myself as a character in something has enabled me to continue to do unbearable things. To have narrative distance. But then there are other times where that way seems to really lie madness, right? Where there's a gap between my experience and my awareness, I guess, maybe, or that narrative distance actually prevents me from connecting to other people in a way that I would like to. Or there's like a metacognitive storm almost that's very chaotic. But then when I fall out, when I really can hold on to the present moment without the storyline, without seeing my life as a story, there are moments where that is a moment of profound sanity. I mean, I'm trying to find an adjective, but the point is there aren't really adjectives. It's really, it's just being, it's being, it's really being in my body, in the present, in not just the small self of my ego. But there are other moments where that's not available to me at all. It's just terrifying and overwhelming.
MS: I think the point, though, is that that's how it is for everybody to some degree or another. Relevant to this movie, you just said that having narrative distance from yourself, from the actual events of your life, allows you to persevere through intolerable situations like your son having cancer. It also, in the context of the movie, allows you to manipulate other people, and treat them like they're not real, and do heinous things.
RZ: Yeah. You know, I just have been writing in my novel about a moment, a real moment, in which we recorded a conversation for Commonplace on the confessional lecture from my book. You ask me… So in the novel, I am sound editing this audio from our conversation. And you ask me, "Why is it important to us that we tell the stories of our lives, that we see our lives as stories and that we tell these stories to other people?" Like, it's ridiculous if you think about it. I basically say, "Well, that's really the question, Mike. I certainly don't have an answer to it.” I was thinking about that again when I was thinking about this movie. There certainly were, in one of the two podcasts, the other one that I listened to, which was, I think, was The Daily. One of the reporters, the journalists who's written a ton about Elizabeth Holmes, when this movie first came out, she was like, "The one thing we don't need is more about Elizabeth Holmes. Why is anyone interested in her anymore? This has been played out fully." Then she saw the movie and she was like, "Oh, this was a really interesting, really artful movie." But she still doesn't feel that there's… There’s no new information in this movie. Well, I guess it depends what we think information is, right? Maybe there is.
MS: I mean, in terms of what the story of Theranos was and what the story of this fraud for which she was convicted, what that was, no, there's not really any new information there. But I think that there's… I think something that a lot of people have a lot of curiosity about is, "Why are you like that?" [laughs]
RZ: Right, right. I think that is what the story...
MS: Or “What do you have to say for yourself?”
RZ: Right, right. There's that fascinating moment where the fact that Elizabeth Holmes was raped comes up. And Nathan Fielder does not go down that path, which I think was really interesting, the way that functioned in the movie. Yeah, I was wondering if you had, either based on this movie or having nothing to do with this movie, any further thoughts about why is it important to tell the stories of our lives in this? Billy invites Nathan Fielder to come and film. Certainly, you could say it's like an infomercial or she's trying to win back sympathy. And to a large extent, it seems like a lot of sympathy has been built for her that wasn't there before. But on another level, it's very confusing why they did this. But also, we're not Elizabeth Holmes, even though sometimes I feel like I'm in an Elizabeth and Nathan Fielder movie. What are we even doing right now? We're talking to each other about this movie, mostly because we just want to talk to each other. Why do we do this?
MS: I think that there are a few different… Well, there are many different ways to approach that question. In the context of this movie, you can ask the question, why did Elizabeth Holmes want to do this movie? Why did Billy want Elizabeth Holmes to do this movie? Why did Nathan Fielder want to do the movie? You could certainly, just based on what's presented in the movie, you could say, based on the things that she says in the movie, you could gather that she was hoping that being able to tell this story might prevent her from having to go to jail. You also see in the movie that she and Billy are trying to start another enterprise that is definitely fraudulent, and they want people to trust them. They want to be able to make money again. They want to be able to do this thing. And not just make money, but have the thrill of defrauding. There's that scene where they're, like, on the phone a whole bunch right before she goes to jail. She says that was exhilarating. You can tell she gets a real thrill out of this. She wants that thrill.
So just like on a purely material level, you can say people want to tell the stories of their lives so that they can control, so they can influence the outcomes in their lives. And I think that's no less true of you and me. Maybe not so much in a financial sense, but certainly in the sense of how we are perceived affects how people treat us. And we want to be treated in a certain way. Or we want not to be treated in certain ways. And maybe, whether consciously or unconsciously, telling our stories from our perspectives is a way of influencing people to do that.
I don't think of that necessarily as something—when you put it in terms that are very stark like that, it sounds very manipulative. The thing is, I think everybody does that. Everybody tries to influence the way that they are perceived so that they can either derive some benefit or avoid some kind of harm. And maybe in an absolute sense, it is manipulative, but I don't think it's the kind of manipulation that people would find fault with, necessarily.
I think another thing with you and me is that I think people also tell stories for their own benefit to say, to try to make sense of the things that happened to them. Or going back to that book that I was just mentioning, where Lulu Miller is trying to assign some cosmic meaning to the fact that she's alive. I think that's another thing that we all do to some degree or another, is try to make sense of what has happened to me? Why has it happened to me? What does it mean that it happened to me? What am I? Who am I? Why am I? I think that we all, to one degree or another, have some amount of preoccupation with those questions. For some of us, it's conscious. For some of us, it's more subconscious.
And I think particularly with people like you and me, you often talk about this sense of you're not sure whether or not you're real. Having an audience helps you feel real. So telling your story is a way of finding an audience and feeling real. I've talked many times about the fact that I've spent my entire life feeling extremely misunderstood, being completely bewildered why people are angry with me or treating me in a certain way. And the ability to tell my story from my own perspective is a way of validating my experience of that, and is a way of trying to get other people to understand me, you know?
There are so many different things that go into why do we want to tell our story? I think the thing is that whether or not people necessarily want to do it through art or media, whether or not they even do it out loud to other people at all, I do think that most people, maybe as close to everybody as makes very little difference, engage in some kind of narrative building, engage in some kind of understanding their life as a story. I kind of think that's just how we're made, you know?
RZ: Okay. A personal question. Then I'm going to ask you what you think Nathan Fielder thinks of Elizabeth Holmes. As somebody who has spent so much of your life feeling misunderstood, how does Nathan Fielder's or the movie's depiction of the unknowability of other people, and maybe of the self or the authentic self, affect you, if at all? Does it change the history of wanting to be understood or wanting maybe to be known, and seeing on this movie how difficult it is to be known and to know others?
MS: I mean, on one level, this movie, in terms of my own personal struggle with things like understanding and expression, it's not relevant at all because, as far as I'm aware, I am always trying as hard as possible to explain myself as clearly and honestly as possible to myself and to others. A lot of times that gets me in trouble because people don't care or want to know, or they'll see it as manipulative or selfish or self-centered for me to explain myself. They don't want me to explain myself. They want me to just do what they want. But at least as far as I'm conscious of, I'm always trying to be as clear and honest in my explanations as possible, which is very much not, I think, what Elizabeth Holmes is doing.
RZ: Right, and you're transparent to yourself, you're saying.
MS: I'm trying to be, you know?
RZ: But mostly, do you feel like you know what you think? You know what's true to you?
MS: I think the other part of this is that it is not a new idea for me that people are inherently unknowable. It's something that I think about all the time. I think also all the time that not only are other people fundamentally unknowable, but that I think oneself is fundamentally unknowable because the thing that you are using to look at yourself is yourself. So it's not possible to see yourself clearly. It's not possible for the thing that is being worked on by your unconscious processes to be clear about what those unconscious processes are.
That there's a guy on TikTok—this is just by way of an example. His name is Dan McClellan. He's a scholar of the Bible and religion. He's got a PhD in biblical studies, in the history and whatever of the Bible as a text, of religion, and the development of religion. He spends a lot of his time on TikTok debunking what people say about the Bible that is not accurate to what the critical consensus is of, the academic understanding of what the Bible says, historically, what it all meant historically at the time, blah, blah, blah. One of the things he talks about is, yes, of course he has biases as well, and that he is as susceptible to bias as anyone else. He's not perfect, but that that is the very point of critical methodology when it comes to study, because the critical methodology is there to try to mitigate as much as possible the influence of those biases, and to make the biases visible so that they can be compensated for or addressed. Even with that framework, that methodology in place, it's still not perfect, but it's at least making the attempt. And it's as good as we've got right now.
I think that's very applicable to my understanding of myself, which is to say, I am biased. I have these unconscious processes that I can't be fully aware of. I'm aware of that fact, and I try to approach my understanding of myself in such a way as to try as hard as possible to compensate for those, to achieve a kind of transparency that is as close as I can get, understanding that I'm never going to get all the way there, and maybe not even get close. What that manifests as is something that you've described repeatedly as me being addicted to doubt. But yeah, like, I don't think that I fully know what I think or what I feel or what is true for me. But I like to flatter myself that I get closer to that than someone would if they were not thinking about it critically.
RZ: All right. What do you think Nathan Fielder thinks about Elizabeth Holmes?
MS: But… [laughs] I just... [laughs]
RZ: Yeah. What?
MS: [laughs] What about you?
RZ: What about me what?
MS: What about... Same question.
RZ: What's the question?
MS: You asked me what this movie and what it has to say about the knowability or unknowability of people, what did that do for me? I think the reason you asked me that question is because it did do something for you.
RZ: Yeah. I feel like there are different me's. Certainly, I think that when I became a mother for the first time, when I had Moses, I became real in a certain way because I knew that he was real, he had physical needs, and I had to be a real mother if I had a real baby. It's like the opposite of The Velveteen Rabbit or something. I don't know. Or maybe it's the same.
And I think that I had in my mind certain experiences that were more real than others, or that were—childbirth being one of them, and extreme pain being one of them, and certain kinds of sex, and going in the ocean. Moments where physical experiences, in my case, where I was not constructing the experience mentally, I was in the experience. And moments in meditation.
And then Abram died, and I think that something new has happened to my brain. Like it kind of broke or broke open. My relationship to reality has shifted again. I don't know that I'm back in the time or experience before becoming a mother. In fact, I don't think so. I imagine that I'm certainly not the only one to have this experience. But even though I feel different since the one-year anniversary, something has shifted, and I feel that I want to get closer and rejoin the world of the living. And I have more capacity to do that. And I want to be re-anchored in time and space. There's also a way in which the reality in this timeline, in this dimension of having given birth and raised a child and watched him die and feeling his presence, but knowing he's no longer in earthly form, and having a sense that he knows me and I know him in ways that we could not know each other when he was alive, and really feeling this and believing this more than I believe a lot of my sensory experiences and the sense data, and my relationships with living people sometimes feel less knowable. Living people feel less knowable sometimes. I feel like, I mean, it's a spiritual awakening. In a way, it reduces my need for knowability, understanding, and the need to explain myself to other people in this lifetime who are alive in a waking state.
That may sound really trippy and abstract, but I think I no longer feel known by anyone to some extent. And I no longer feel knowable to anyone. And I no longer feel knowable to myself in the way that I used to imagine. And in a way, I'm less freaked out by that than I used to be. Part of it is caring less about what other people think. And part of that, I think, inevitably, is not trying to be selling anything to anyone, like, literally, but also figuratively.
The downside of that is I'm having a hard time remembering what's important to me, and what's important, you know? I've had a very difficult time lately, before watching the movie, remembering what's important to people. I think what's important to Elizabeth Holmes… I mean, I can see that excitement that she feels when she is—she's really good at—she feels that her gift, that her purpose on earth is to convince people somehow of something. In her case, it has to do with selling things and raising money, but also inventing things. It's not real. But unfortunately, it did actually hurt a lot of real people, and it was fraud, and it was bad. But if she had been a different kind of performance artist, like Nathan Fielder is a performance artist, he perhaps unwittingly and unintentionally, has convinced a lot of people that maybe Elizabeth Holmes did not commit fraud. So that's a magic trick right there. But in a lot of ways, I don't relate to any of this bullshit. I felt like none of this is real. By that, I really meant the money and the fame, if that makes any sense. I think the relationship between Nathan Fielder and Elizabeth Holmes has moments of intense realness.
MS: Hmm.
RZ: Yeah. All right. What do you think Nathan Fielder thinks about Elizabeth Holmes? Tell us.
MS: I think that he is aware that she is lying to him and manipulating him intentionally. I think that you can see that based on what he brings to her attention. I think that the way that he pushes back on some of the things that she says and the kinds of things that he shows her, whether it is the Hulu series when they watch that together or whether it is when he's showing her that "Who's on First?" sketch, he doesn't believe her. He doesn't believe that she is being honest in the things that he is saying to her. I also think that she is very gifted at manipulating people, at getting them to feel a connection with her, whether it's sympathy or excitement or something. And I think that that works on him, too. And I think he's aware that it's working on him.
RZ: He genuinely likes her.
MS: Yes, I think that he genuinely does like her and care about her, and feels a connection with her while at the same time being aware that she is manufacturing that on purpose.
RZ: Yeah, I think that—I have no way of knowing this, but I have seen some of his other stuff. I'm also thinking of this thing where he hired an actor, a female actor, to basically say, "I love you, I love you, I love you," over and over again to him. We don't have time to really get into the feminist part of it, but I do think he genuinely likes her, he does not believe her, and on some level, I think this is the nature of his relationship with women. I don't think he believes that it can really be any other way. And to some extent—I'm going to pretend I'm whispering now—I am not sure that I really believe men, and yet I still like them. That was a little subpart of this whole thing that was very interesting to me, the way that gender played into this. I want to say one thing, which, if I don't say it, I'm going to regret it, which is, have you watched the movie Stories We Tell by Sarah Polley?
MS: No, I've been meaning to watch that for years. And I've heard other people say, “If you liked this movie, you must watch that other movie.”
RZ: So I don't want to say anything else about it. I would love for you to watch it. I would love to rewatch it. That is a movie I've seen many, many times. I saw it in the theater without knowing anything about it. It's a very, very important movie to me. I think it won't hold up in a certain way after this movie, but in other ways it really will. I would love to talk to you about that because it's very related. I love that movie. I think that movie is much more influential than it gets credit for.
MS: Hmm. I literally, last week, I think, saw someone on social media say that Sarah Polley walked so that Nathan Fielder could run.
RZ: Yeah. Watch it. Let's do another one.
MS: [laughter] Okay.
RZ: All right.
MS: Can I just tell you before we end, since the format of the show originally was to talk, and then talk about the talk?
RZ: Yeah.
MS: This is the first time in a really long time where the conversation that we had on the mic felt like the way that it felt in the beginning.
RZ: Yeah. I'm trying not to get too attached to how I feel. But I really feel a big, big shift. I really feel okay. I feel connected. I feel much more connected to you. Not to everything and everyone, but I feel like everything between us for a long time has been with a lot of disruption, you know. I don't know, I just keep thinking of Star Trek metaphors, but I've been out of phase. And I feel back in phase somehow. Yeah.
MS: Yeah, I can tell.
RZ: I'm glad you like this me more than grief hermit me.
MS: [laughter] I always like you, but I'm glad to see that there's been a shift.
RZ: Thank you. And thanks for sticking with me.
MS: You're my friend, Rachel.
RZ: Yeah.
[Music]
Mike Sakasegawa: You've been listening to Hey, It’s Me with Rachel Zucker and Mike Sakasegawa.
Rachel Zucker: Hey, It's Me is a production of Rachel Zucker and Likewise Media.
MS: Editing and transcription for this episode is by Shea Aguinaldo, with additional editing by Mike Sakasegawa, and the music is by Podington Bear.
RZ: You can find more information about the show, including contact information and transcripts, at heyitsmepodcast.com.
MS: If you'd like to hear more from us, you can find Rachel's other show, Commonplace, at Commonplace.today.
MS: And you can find Mike's other show, Keep the Channel Open, at keepthechannelopen.com. Thanks for spending this time with us.
RZ and MS, together: Take care.